So last night, we ventured out of our comfortable South Beach 'hood, along with our friend Candida to...The Mission! Yipes, on a Saturday night?! To a restaurant that doesn't even accept resies? To a place about as big as a troll's first studio apartment? Are we insane?! Well, we had been drinking 'ritas all day...
Anyhoo, this place has some serious buzz, and our chef buds Spencer & Sarah can't stop yapping about it. So off we went, even scored a taxi there within a few minutes.

First impression? Well, my first impression occurred the first time I heard the name of the place. Whenever I hear the word
'Beretta' I think of one of my fave crime series in the '70s by the same name.
Yeah yeah, I hear y'all. The '70s?! You were alive in the '70s?! Simmer down. It's called late-night reruns on cable.
Anyway, he's also the same guy that shot and killed...I mean allegedly shot & killed...his wife a few
years back. Maybe his parrot told him to do it.
But enough rambling for now. Back to the story. Second impression - Happenin' place, bitches. I mean, you gotta bring your sham wow to hang with the folks here. Cool space, right on the corner of 23rd & Valencia with lots of windows and natural light, a big bar down the left side, open kitchen in the rear and small tables around the perimeter. Good lighting, and a big communal table in the middle We're not huge fans of the communal tables ourselves, but whatever.
So I tried to call ahead of time, since even though they don't take resies, they say you can call up to 45 minutes ahead of time and they'll put your name on the list. But, the phone never picked up and when we arrived were told it'd be TWO HOURS. Ha. They obviously didn't realize we were VdV. But, with the beauty and charms of Janine and Candida, we miraculously weaseled a few seats at the bar. Let the games begin!
First off, I noticed one of the bartenders was this d-bag that used to work at Tres Agaves. Always playing with his hair and makin' drinks at the same time - no shit - and talking on his cell phone behind the bar. Good for us, we were at the other end of the bar and our dude was a pro. Cool cat with some mutton chop-type beard from NoLa.
So, I know it seems like I'm being a complete snitty bioottch right now. So let's cut to the chase - we love Beretta. A solid 8.5 outta 10 in my book. So that said let me ramble on and share some insights.
First, upgrade your tap water, for chrissakes! Or your pipes or wherever you get your non-bottled water from. Yuck. It's like drinking from the fetid swamp in the movie Cabin Fever. Seriously. You are better than this.
Second, we ordered up a couple Cosmos. Nope, no cranberry juice. The only had 'organic Elderberry juice'. WTF? I mean, I'm from Eugene and all but how 'bout stockin some Ocean Spray?! That said, the elderberry Cosmos were pretty tasty!
So let's get down to business my furry friends, like Tom Colicchio from Top Chef says 'it's all about the food'.
Wanna hear it? Here it goes:
Appys: Zucchini Parmigiana with Scamorza & Basil, I am not kidding I could gorge on this for breakfast lunch and din din. But what the hell is Scamorza?! Awesome sauce, baked perfectly and slightly burnt around the edges with thin, tender Zucchini. More stuff like this and J turns veggie. Then we had the Meatballs in Spicy Tomato Sauce. More sauce! I thought these 3 big balls were a little dense, but well cooked and again..that f'ing sauce is a constant winna! Last but not...well, maybe least: the Creamy Polenta with Gorgonzola. This was actually really good, the polenta was exquisite (who ever call polenta exquisite?!) and the only knock was that the cheese was a teensy overwhelming.
Mains: 'Za all the way. Woo Hoo!
Serious pizza menu here, about a dozen or so. Spencer's fave is the Spicy Italian Sausage, Panna & Spring Onions. We trust him but went our own way. Two pies, a Margherita with Burrata,
and the Funghi Misti, Tomato, Fontina & Thyme.
And the reviews are in!
First, the crust. Crust aficionados that we are, we rate this crust as crust-i-licious! Awesome. Very thin, and similar to the crust at Lombardi's in Manhattan, as it holds its shape and is slightly crispy. Excellent! How excellent, you ask? I stashed some crust bits in my pocket so I could snack on them later on at home.
Beretta goes generous on the sauce, which is slightly sweet and also robust tasting. Like, super fresh bitch. DIg it! And the toppings are OTH fresh, the Burrata cheese dollops were jeesy good, the 'shrooms were awesome and the spices were dead on. And we found a partial slice the next AM and chowed it down like nobody's business. Slurp. Nothing tests good 'Za like the morning after taste.
We deem Beretta as one of the Top 5 pizzas in all of SF! And to boot, they have one of our fave unknown wines on the list, a Nero D'Avola, a kick you in the teeth red wine from Sicily. Woo Hoo! And they also have a throw-down solid cocktail menu that I'm definitely treating like my bitch next time around.
GO NOW! Like I said, 8 1/2 outta 10. Giggidy!
Beretta
1199 Valencia St
(between 22nd St & 23rd St)
San Francisco, CA 94110
(415) 695-1199
Recent Comments